Both Sides Now: Perspectives from a Publisher-Writer
In Art & Fear, David Bayles & Ted Orland said:
"Uncertainty is the essential, inevitable and all-pervasive companion to your desire to make art. And tolerance for uncertainty is the prerequisite to succeeding."
Or, John Steinbeck put it simply:
"The profession of book-writing makes horse-racing seem like a solid, stable business."
These are the sorts of statements you don't really understand until you really understand them. I interview writers on the Life on Words podcast: New York Times bestselling writers, writers who have won awards like the Newbery Honor and who have had multiple Emmy and Grammy nominations for their work with words. There have been writers whose books are now Hallmark and Lifetime movies. There have been others just starting out. Novelists, poets, songwriters, a comedy writer.
And it's been the same from all of them. Putting your words out there isn't only uncertain and sometimes soul-crushing, but it's also terrifying. Sometimes you don't know where your work will be presented, if at all, and when it finally is presented, you don't know how it will be received. I would have thought an end to that might come eventually, once you're "successful," but apparently not.
Also apparently, nobody breezes through. Sure, one of the authors debuted on the New York Times list with her first book, but that book didn't happen until she had amassed 400 rejections. Along those lines, I interviewed a literary agent who said you're not even making a dent unless you send out at least 100 queries to find an agent to represent your work (upcoming podcast episode).
Why is finding a place for your art so rough? Is the work so bad that it's destined to face rejection until somebody breaks down and takes it? Not at all.
The same agent who suggested the 100-query starting point said she typically receives 500 queries every month. I edit Inkhorn Review, a literary journal that focuses on poetry and short prose, and I've been surprised to see that even as a brand-new journal I'm getting 500 submissions a month . . . and bear in mind that a submission typically includes at least 3 poems or 2-3 pieces of prose.
Apparently a lot of people want to be writers. But the long and short of it is, who can read that many submissions and not pass on many very qualified pieces?
I've dipped my own toe into the water as a writer. In typical "Terry" fashion, I'm not taking the easy route (as if there were one anyway). I've decided, of all things, to be a poet. So immediately forget about all those New York Times premieres and Hallmark Channel movies. I've joined the legions of introspective folks who are destined to never make a living from their art. All that said, am I discouraged by the odds? Does being one of the 500+ club, those in the 500-query or 500-submission slush piles, daunt me?
Of course it does. But hearing and experiencing things from both sides of the fence as a writer and publisher who has regular conversations with those who do the same, gives me great hope. Submission readers, editors, agents, and others really are not saying "Johnny Can't Write." When they hedge their rejections with phrases like "not right for us right now" and "it's not a comment on your work," they really mean it. If a popular quarterly journal receives thousands of submissions for each issue and if literary agents receive an unreadable number of queries every month, how could I possibly take the rejection personally or as an evaluation of my work?
What I'm gambling on is a numbers game. I've written a verse novel (because I didn't think it was challenging to write a normal novel?) and so far have sent it to 147 agents, and I really don't expect any of them to bite. There's a pun in that because the verse novel features a pastor-turned-vampire in 1889 Seattle (of course that's not what it's about—this is poetry after all). So not only did I subject myself to all the usual difficulties, but I also wrote a type of book almost nobody will want to publish. And yet I have hope. Oddly and for no apparent reason.
Bayles and Orland said artists need tolerance for uncertainty. Maybe I would add that they need a certain proclivity for delusion.
Member discussion